{ "meta": { "seed": 20261007, "rng": "numpy PCG64; child streams SeedSequence(seed, spawn_key=(crc32(task name), chunk index))", "quick": false, "python": "3.14.6", "numpy": "2.4.4", "workers": 12, "chunk_games": 250, "rules": { "board": "10x10", "classic": "5 ships of 5, 4, 3, 3, 2 squares; ships may touch (Torpedo default) but not overlap", "classic10": "10 ships of 4, 3, 3, 2, 2, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1 squares; ships may not touch, even diagonally; water around a sunk ship is revealed", "shots": "one shot at a time; every shot counts (Torpedo's default Hit Streak rule gives extra turns but never changes how many shots a side needs)", "information": "hit/miss reported; a sunk ship is announced with its class and squares (Torpedo shows every wreck)" }, "gibbs_sweeps": 100, "history_games_for_learned_expert": 20, "timings": { "heatmaps_wall_s": 215.5, "games_wall_s": 533.0, "total_wall_s": 748.8 } }, "games_classic": { "random": { "n": 100000, "mean": 95.4, "sd": 4.81, "se_mean": 0.015, "median": 97.0, "p10": 89.0, "p90": 100.0, "min": 50, "max": 100, "pct_within_50": 0.0, "histogram_shots": { "50": 1, "56": 1, "57": 5, "58": 2, "59": 3, "60": 1, "61": 1, "62": 2, "63": 5, "64": 3, "65": 8, "66": 6, "67": 9, "68": 16, "69": 13, "70": 23, "71": 39, "72": 50, "73": 70, "74": 75, "75": 92, "76": 117, "77": 173, "78": 197, "79": 267, "80": 341, "81": 419, "82": 515, "83": 639, "84": 748, "85": 951, "86": 1189, "87": 1462, "88": 1805, "89": 2147, "90": 2587, "91": 3213, "92": 3954, "93": 4737, "94": 5614, "95": 6958, "96": 8259, "97": 10034, "98": 11944, "99": 14179, "100": 17126 }, "label": "Random shots", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 37.7, "ms_per_game": 0.38 }, "hunt_target": { "n": 100000, "mean": 62.15, "sd": 14.06, "se_mean": 0.044, "median": 62.0, "p10": 44.0, "p90": 81.0, "min": 20, "max": 100, "pct_within_50": 22.12, "histogram_shots": { "20": 1, "23": 4, "24": 2, "25": 13, "26": 19, "27": 45, "28": 62, "29": 104, "30": 126, "31": 139, "32": 233, "33": 290, "34": 371, "35": 425, "36": 523, "37": 623, "38": 738, "39": 851, "40": 987, "41": 1106, "42": 1204, "43": 1349, "44": 1503, "45": 1591, "46": 1733, "47": 1818, "48": 1997, "49": 2065, "50": 2203, "51": 2277, "52": 2417, "53": 2391, "54": 2384, "55": 2530, "56": 2569, "57": 2535, "58": 2744, "59": 2558, "60": 2555, "61": 2683, "62": 2637, "63": 2527, "64": 2550, "65": 2544, "66": 2514, "67": 2517, "68": 2307, "69": 2203, "70": 2209, "71": 2105, "72": 2001, "73": 1972, "74": 1868, "75": 1761, "76": 1624, "77": 1593, "78": 1498, "79": 1426, "80": 1291, "81": 1205, "82": 1160, "83": 1102, "84": 949, "85": 892, "86": 854, "87": 745, "88": 746, "89": 581, "90": 524, "91": 461, "92": 405, "93": 340, "94": 300, "95": 239, "96": 198, "97": 172, "98": 104, "99": 73, "100": 35 }, "label": "Hunt/target", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 39.9, "ms_per_game": 0.4 }, "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 100000, "mean": 55.13, "sd": 8.56, "se_mean": 0.027, "median": 56.0, "p10": 43.0, "p90": 65.0, "min": 20, "max": 74, "pct_within_50": 28.55, "histogram_shots": { "20": 1, "21": 2, "23": 6, "24": 6, "25": 22, "26": 24, "27": 38, "28": 58, "29": 78, "30": 109, "31": 168, "32": 219, "33": 306, "34": 346, "35": 475, "36": 593, "37": 742, "38": 909, "39": 980, "40": 1210, "41": 1301, "42": 1487, "43": 1743, "44": 1845, "45": 2114, "46": 2302, "47": 2548, "48": 2784, "49": 2953, "50": 3185, "51": 3373, "52": 3480, "53": 3801, "54": 3787, "55": 4019, "56": 4190, "57": 4228, "58": 4429, "59": 4388, "60": 4505, "61": 4520, "62": 4507, "63": 4440, "64": 4135, "65": 3873, "66": 3286, "67": 2590, "68": 1810, "69": 1098, "70": 548, "71": 290, "72": 113, "73": 26, "74": 10 }, "label": "Hunt/target + parity", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 37.3, "ms_per_game": 0.37 }, "density": { "n": 100000, "mean": 45.05, "sd": 9.08, "se_mean": 0.029, "median": 44.0, "p10": 34.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 19, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 73.58, "histogram_shots": { "19": 1, "20": 4, "21": 12, "22": 24, "23": 42, "24": 114, "25": 175, "26": 249, "27": 432, "28": 636, "29": 847, "30": 1126, "31": 1535, "32": 1862, "33": 2295, "34": 2515, "35": 3009, "36": 3279, "37": 3644, "38": 3861, "39": 4025, "40": 4229, "41": 4247, "42": 4280, "43": 4073, "44": 4056, "45": 4041, "46": 3922, "47": 4042, "48": 3816, "49": 3591, "50": 3601, "51": 3209, "52": 2884, "53": 2490, "54": 2125, "55": 1812, "56": 1612, "57": 1504, "58": 1468, "59": 1429, "60": 1401, "61": 1317, "62": 1123, "63": 965, "64": 749, "65": 629, "66": 585, "67": 424, "68": 320, "69": 209, "70": 100, "71": 39, "72": 19, "73": 2 }, "label": "Probability density", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 284.5, "ms_per_game": 2.85 }, "torpedo_beginner": { "n": 100000, "mean": 73.39, "sd": 10.54, "se_mean": 0.033, "median": 73.0, "p10": 60.0, "p90": 87.0, "min": 32, "max": 100, "pct_within_50": 1.3, "histogram_shots": { "32": 1, "34": 1, "35": 5, "36": 4, "37": 6, "38": 8, "39": 13, "40": 10, "41": 17, "42": 37, "43": 51, "44": 65, "45": 80, "46": 113, "47": 160, "48": 195, "49": 218, "50": 315, "51": 393, "52": 464, "53": 612, "54": 700, "55": 898, "56": 1033, "57": 1189, "58": 1401, "59": 1556, "60": 1839, "61": 1978, "62": 2254, "63": 2343, "64": 2643, "65": 2808, "66": 2993, "67": 3136, "68": 3258, "69": 3392, "70": 3514, "71": 3690, "72": 3636, "73": 3631, "74": 3712, "75": 3540, "76": 3562, "77": 3427, "78": 3401, "79": 3034, "80": 3020, "81": 2788, "82": 2689, "83": 2418, "84": 2253, "85": 2095, "86": 1941, "87": 1666, "88": 1536, "89": 1448, "90": 1225, "91": 1039, "92": 894, "93": 818, "94": 687, "95": 550, "96": 483, "97": 364, "98": 333, "99": 231, "100": 186 }, "label": "Torpedo Beginner", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 70.5, "ms_per_game": 0.7 }, "torpedo_easy": { "n": 100000, "mean": 64.74, "sd": 13.09, "se_mean": 0.041, "median": 64.0, "p10": 48.0, "p90": 83.0, "min": 26, "max": 100, "pct_within_50": 14.46, "histogram_shots": { "26": 2, "27": 2, "28": 3, "29": 4, "30": 9, "31": 23, "32": 35, "33": 44, "34": 84, "35": 106, "36": 169, "37": 217, "38": 287, "39": 380, "40": 486, "41": 601, "42": 679, "43": 821, "44": 1008, "45": 1192, "46": 1332, "47": 1521, "48": 1663, "49": 1812, "50": 1983, "51": 2141, "52": 2318, "53": 2397, "54": 2477, "55": 2582, "56": 2665, "57": 2785, "58": 2861, "59": 2781, "60": 2783, "61": 2856, "62": 2760, "63": 2772, "64": 2775, "65": 2771, "66": 2675, "67": 2708, "68": 2553, "69": 2594, "70": 2477, "71": 2385, "72": 2257, "73": 2228, "74": 2142, "75": 1998, "76": 1913, "77": 1895, "78": 1696, "79": 1616, "80": 1529, "81": 1410, "82": 1362, "83": 1222, "84": 1136, "85": 1094, "86": 980, "87": 852, "88": 792, "89": 733, "90": 674, "91": 556, "92": 480, "93": 400, "94": 372, "95": 313, "96": 256, "97": 209, "98": 141, "99": 99, "100": 66 }, "label": "Torpedo Easy", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 47.9, "ms_per_game": 0.48 }, "torpedo_normal": { "n": 100000, "mean": 49.69, "sd": 8.27, "se_mean": 0.026, "median": 50.0, "p10": 38.0, "p90": 60.0, "min": 20, "max": 70, "pct_within_50": 51.7, "histogram_shots": { "20": 5, "21": 5, "22": 15, "23": 30, "24": 45, "25": 83, "26": 126, "27": 175, "28": 223, "29": 306, "30": 390, "31": 507, "32": 661, "33": 771, "34": 907, "35": 1129, "36": 1336, "37": 1552, "38": 1801, "39": 2015, "40": 2346, "41": 2677, "42": 2831, "43": 3160, "44": 3442, "45": 3625, "46": 3984, "47": 4263, "48": 4235, "49": 4547, "50": 4508, "51": 4561, "52": 4427, "53": 4276, "54": 3923, "55": 4003, "56": 3833, "57": 3746, "58": 3398, "59": 3373, "60": 3101, "61": 2837, "62": 2510, "63": 1835, "64": 1284, "65": 689, "66": 343, "67": 116, "68": 36, "69": 7, "70": 2 }, "label": "Torpedo Normal", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 247.4, "ms_per_game": 2.47 }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 100000, "mean": 44.88, "sd": 9.19, "se_mean": 0.029, "median": 44.0, "p10": 33.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 18, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 74.38, "histogram_shots": { "18": 1, "19": 4, "20": 4, "21": 21, "22": 43, "23": 71, "24": 149, "25": 243, "26": 361, "27": 464, "28": 737, "29": 921, "30": 1265, "31": 1516, "32": 1909, "33": 2321, "34": 2598, "35": 3019, "36": 3303, "37": 3447, "38": 3982, "39": 4045, "40": 4164, "41": 4200, "42": 4272, "43": 4167, "44": 4072, "45": 4110, "46": 3997, "47": 4016, "48": 3796, "49": 3748, "50": 3414, "51": 3043, "52": 2590, "53": 2231, "54": 1890, "55": 1693, "56": 1610, "57": 1592, "58": 1496, "59": 1434, "60": 1468, "61": 1328, "62": 1178, "63": 951, "64": 815, "65": 636, "66": 544, "67": 460, "68": 290, "69": 196, "70": 119, "71": 39, "72": 12, "73": 5 }, "label": "Torpedo Hard", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 220.3, "ms_per_game": 2.2 }, "torpedo_expert": { "n": 100000, "mean": 44.78, "sd": 9.12, "se_mean": 0.029, "median": 44.0, "p10": 33.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 20, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 74.53, "histogram_shots": { "20": 10, "21": 14, "22": 42, "23": 59, "24": 119, "25": 197, "26": 342, "27": 554, "28": 724, "29": 1033, "30": 1281, "31": 1518, "32": 1972, "33": 2315, "34": 2659, "35": 3099, "36": 3373, "37": 3558, "38": 3908, "39": 3935, "40": 4118, "41": 4185, "42": 4257, "43": 4200, "44": 4090, "45": 4087, "46": 4014, "47": 3903, "48": 3797, "49": 3661, "50": 3508, "51": 3062, "52": 2664, "53": 2350, "54": 2051, "55": 1700, "56": 1655, "57": 1495, "58": 1511, "59": 1417, "60": 1420, "61": 1235, "62": 1077, "63": 968, "64": 762, "65": 628, "66": 498, "67": 375, "68": 260, "69": 185, "70": 98, "71": 40, "72": 13, "73": 4 }, "label": "Torpedo Expert (no history)", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 237.1, "ms_per_game": 2.37 } }, "games_classic10": { "random": { "n": 50000, "mean": 75.46, "sd": 6.39, "se_mean": 0.029, "median": 76.0, "p10": 67.0, "p90": 84.0, "min": 44, "max": 98, "pct_within_50": 0.02, "histogram_shots": { "44": 1, "46": 1, "47": 1, "49": 4, "50": 2, "51": 7, "52": 1, "53": 16, "54": 17, "55": 37, "56": 48, "57": 75, "58": 105, "59": 152, "60": 213, "61": 248, "62": 367, "63": 476, "64": 640, "65": 816, "66": 980, "67": 1253, "68": 1472, "69": 1768, "70": 2025, "71": 2323, "72": 2587, "73": 2852, "74": 2994, "75": 3114, "76": 3046, "77": 3072, "78": 2969, "79": 2764, "80": 2546, "81": 2298, "82": 1953, "83": 1693, "84": 1387, "85": 1050, "86": 803, "87": 632, "88": 450, "89": 316, "90": 188, "91": 108, "92": 57, "93": 44, "94": 19, "95": 6, "96": 2, "97": 1, "98": 1 }, "label": "Random shots", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 22.9, "ms_per_game": 0.46 }, "hunt_target": { "n": 50000, "mean": 63.18, "sd": 6.9, "se_mean": 0.031, "median": 63.0, "p10": 54.0, "p90": 72.0, "min": 36, "max": 89, "pct_within_50": 4.05, "histogram_shots": { "36": 1, "37": 3, "38": 9, "39": 9, "40": 13, "41": 31, "42": 42, "43": 61, "44": 87, "45": 118, "46": 179, "47": 246, "48": 295, "49": 403, "50": 527, "51": 627, "52": 759, "53": 920, "54": 1044, "55": 1370, "56": 1620, "57": 1803, "58": 2048, "59": 2252, "60": 2435, "61": 2686, "62": 2681, "63": 2816, "64": 2870, "65": 2925, "66": 2832, "67": 2608, "68": 2393, "69": 2225, "70": 1864, "71": 1696, "72": 1416, "73": 1104, "74": 827, "75": 655, "76": 498, "77": 352, "78": 250, "79": 145, "80": 114, "81": 63, "82": 35, "83": 21, "84": 12, "85": 3, "86": 2, "87": 3, "88": 1, "89": 1 }, "label": "Hunt/target", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 39.4, "ms_per_game": 0.79 }, "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 50000, "mean": 62.95, "sd": 6.96, "se_mean": 0.031, "median": 63.0, "p10": 54.0, "p90": 72.0, "min": 32, "max": 88, "pct_within_50": 4.39, "histogram_shots": { "32": 1, "33": 1, "35": 3, "36": 2, "37": 7, "38": 13, "39": 12, "40": 28, "41": 39, "42": 53, "43": 73, "44": 114, "45": 131, "46": 191, "47": 260, "48": 317, "49": 431, "50": 518, "51": 646, "52": 858, "53": 1003, "54": 1122, "55": 1302, "56": 1565, "57": 1877, "58": 2090, "59": 2307, "60": 2468, "61": 2682, "62": 2800, "63": 2843, "64": 2884, "65": 2883, "66": 2761, "67": 2482, "68": 2433, "69": 2125, "70": 1909, "71": 1551, "72": 1299, "73": 1037, "74": 816, "75": 624, "76": 487, "77": 346, "78": 229, "79": 129, "80": 101, "81": 71, "82": 24, "83": 33, "84": 12, "85": 4, "86": 2, "88": 1 }, "label": "Hunt/target + parity", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 26.4, "ms_per_game": 0.53 }, "density": { "n": 50000, "mean": 57.55, "sd": 7.16, "se_mean": 0.032, "median": 58.0, "p10": 48.0, "p90": 67.0, "min": 31, "max": 82, "pct_within_50": 16.5, "histogram_shots": { "31": 4, "32": 2, "33": 12, "34": 12, "35": 25, "36": 49, "37": 58, "38": 81, "39": 136, "40": 187, "41": 235, "42": 334, "43": 418, "44": 528, "45": 645, "46": 775, "47": 942, "48": 1108, "49": 1249, "50": 1452, "51": 1718, "52": 1953, "53": 2030, "54": 2311, "55": 2435, "56": 2504, "57": 2753, "58": 2764, "59": 2816, "60": 2735, "61": 2599, "62": 2500, "63": 2273, "64": 2005, "65": 1754, "66": 1531, "67": 1243, "68": 1047, "69": 828, "70": 607, "71": 449, "72": 312, "73": 202, "74": 154, "75": 101, "76": 62, "77": 25, "78": 19, "79": 11, "80": 3, "81": 2, "82": 2 }, "label": "Probability density", "group": "reference", "cpu_seconds": 190.7, "ms_per_game": 3.81 }, "torpedo_beginner": { "n": 50000, "mean": 67.14, "sd": 6.86, "se_mean": 0.031, "median": 67.0, "p10": 58.0, "p90": 76.0, "min": 39, "max": 91, "pct_within_50": 1.13, "histogram_shots": { "39": 2, "40": 5, "41": 4, "42": 7, "43": 10, "44": 18, "45": 28, "46": 44, "47": 66, "48": 88, "49": 124, "50": 169, "51": 256, "52": 270, "53": 330, "54": 482, "55": 631, "56": 754, "57": 988, "58": 1141, "59": 1392, "60": 1548, "61": 1778, "62": 2037, "63": 2327, "64": 2418, "65": 2704, "66": 2766, "67": 2962, "68": 2870, "69": 2913, "70": 2705, "71": 2645, "72": 2405, "73": 2213, "74": 1931, "75": 1631, "76": 1326, "77": 1089, "78": 846, "79": 621, "80": 455, "81": 355, "82": 253, "83": 140, "84": 121, "85": 57, "86": 34, "87": 23, "88": 8, "89": 6, "90": 3, "91": 1 }, "label": "Torpedo Beginner", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 34.3, "ms_per_game": 0.69 }, "torpedo_easy": { "n": 50000, "mean": 64.18, "sd": 6.91, "se_mean": 0.031, "median": 65.0, "p10": 55.0, "p90": 73.0, "min": 31, "max": 88, "pct_within_50": 3.14, "histogram_shots": { "31": 1, "35": 1, "36": 4, "37": 1, "38": 2, "39": 10, "40": 19, "41": 24, "42": 37, "43": 34, "44": 61, "45": 104, "46": 121, "47": 188, "48": 223, "49": 341, "50": 398, "51": 507, "52": 594, "53": 780, "54": 933, "55": 1056, "56": 1333, "57": 1542, "58": 1761, "59": 2019, "60": 2215, "61": 2421, "62": 2658, "63": 2747, "64": 2837, "65": 2912, "66": 2944, "67": 2812, "68": 2659, "69": 2411, "70": 2310, "71": 1904, "72": 1656, "73": 1347, "74": 1114, "75": 877, "76": 661, "77": 477, "78": 308, "79": 250, "80": 157, "81": 91, "82": 55, "83": 34, "84": 23, "85": 14, "86": 6, "87": 4, "88": 2 }, "label": "Torpedo Easy", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 26.3, "ms_per_game": 0.53 }, "torpedo_normal": { "n": 50000, "mean": 59.27, "sd": 7.11, "se_mean": 0.032, "median": 60.0, "p10": 50.0, "p90": 68.0, "min": 31, "max": 86, "pct_within_50": 11.51, "histogram_shots": { "31": 2, "32": 4, "33": 1, "34": 9, "35": 12, "36": 14, "37": 29, "38": 45, "39": 79, "40": 99, "41": 129, "42": 201, "43": 248, "44": 310, "45": 368, "46": 527, "47": 669, "48": 781, "49": 1020, "50": 1208, "51": 1310, "52": 1501, "53": 1773, "54": 1972, "55": 2209, "56": 2314, "57": 2565, "58": 2773, "59": 2810, "60": 2818, "61": 2779, "62": 2685, "63": 2553, "64": 2443, "65": 2204, "66": 1839, "67": 1681, "68": 1355, "69": 1158, "70": 921, "71": 717, "72": 582, "73": 400, "74": 299, "75": 220, "76": 124, "77": 99, "78": 62, "79": 41, "80": 20, "81": 10, "82": 5, "83": 1, "84": 1, "86": 1 }, "label": "Torpedo Normal", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 31.7, "ms_per_game": 0.63 }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 50000, "mean": 57.51, "sd": 7.14, "se_mean": 0.032, "median": 58.0, "p10": 48.0, "p90": 67.0, "min": 30, "max": 82, "pct_within_50": 16.62, "histogram_shots": { "30": 1, "31": 3, "32": 8, "33": 10, "34": 12, "35": 26, "36": 42, "37": 64, "38": 89, "39": 123, "40": 162, "41": 242, "42": 334, "43": 408, "44": 507, "45": 635, "46": 795, "47": 883, "48": 1164, "49": 1324, "50": 1478, "51": 1612, "52": 1991, "53": 2183, "54": 2286, "55": 2534, "56": 2703, "57": 2722, "58": 2729, "59": 2695, "60": 2617, "61": 2576, "62": 2546, "63": 2173, "64": 2024, "65": 1767, "66": 1517, "67": 1298, "68": 998, "69": 790, "70": 553, "71": 445, "72": 345, "73": 225, "74": 127, "75": 101, "76": 50, "77": 43, "78": 21, "79": 10, "80": 7, "81": 1, "82": 1 }, "label": "Torpedo Hard", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 196.1, "ms_per_game": 3.92 }, "torpedo_expert": { "n": 50000, "mean": 57.59, "sd": 7.12, "se_mean": 0.032, "median": 58.0, "p10": 48.0, "p90": 66.0, "min": 29, "max": 81, "pct_within_50": 16.22, "histogram_shots": { "29": 1, "30": 1, "31": 3, "32": 5, "33": 14, "34": 6, "35": 22, "36": 33, "37": 63, "38": 86, "39": 127, "40": 197, "41": 259, "42": 320, "43": 393, "44": 503, "45": 626, "46": 787, "47": 932, "48": 1096, "49": 1218, "50": 1420, "51": 1696, "52": 1962, "53": 2015, "54": 2270, "55": 2432, "56": 2594, "57": 2658, "58": 2929, "59": 2762, "60": 2720, "61": 2654, "62": 2422, "63": 2334, "64": 2087, "65": 1826, "66": 1562, "67": 1280, "68": 977, "69": 775, "70": 598, "71": 415, "72": 335, "73": 224, "74": 131, "75": 98, "76": 56, "77": 41, "78": 20, "79": 8, "80": 4, "81": 3 }, "label": "Torpedo Expert (no history)", "group": "torpedo", "cpu_seconds": 218.9, "ms_per_game": 4.38 } }, "placement_experiment": { "styles": { "uniform": "Uniform random legal layout", "edge_ring": "Edge-hugging: every ship lies flat along an edge (all squares on the outer ring)", "edge_touch": "Edge-touching: every ship has at least one square on the outer ring", "centre": "Centre cluster: every square inside the central 6x6 (C3-H8)", "cluster": "All ships touching: one orthogonally connected group of ships" }, "n_per_cell": 20000, "table": { "uniform": { "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 20000, "mean": 55.11, "sd": 8.6, "se_mean": 0.061, "median": 56.0, "p10": 43.0, "p90": 65.10000000000218, "min": 22, "max": 75, "pct_within_50": 28.85, "label": "Hunt/target + parity" }, "density": { "n": 20000, "mean": 45.1, "sd": 9.07, "se_mean": 0.064, "median": 44.0, "p10": 34.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 21, "max": 72, "pct_within_50": 73.55, "label": "Probability density" }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 20000, "mean": 44.76, "sd": 9.26, "se_mean": 0.066, "median": 44.0, "p10": 33.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 19, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 74.88, "label": "Torpedo Hard" }, "torpedo_expert_learned": { "n": 20000, "mean": 44.81, "sd": 9.16, "se_mean": 0.065, "median": 44.0, "p10": 33.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 20, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 74.72, "label": "Torpedo Expert (after 20 games vs. this player)" } }, "edge_ring": { "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 20000, "mean": 53.43, "sd": 7.92, "se_mean": 0.056, "median": 55.0, "p10": 42.0, "p90": 63.0, "min": 24, "max": 69, "pct_within_50": 33.51, "label": "Hunt/target + parity" }, "density": { "n": 20000, "mean": 51.32, "sd": 8.64, "se_mean": 0.061, "median": 52.0, "p10": 39.0, "p90": 62.0, "min": 31, "max": 75, "pct_within_50": 41.97, "label": "Probability density" }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 20000, "mean": 50.66, "sd": 8.26, "se_mean": 0.058, "median": 50.0, "p10": 40.0, "p90": 62.0, "min": 31, "max": 76, "pct_within_50": 50.72, "label": "Torpedo Hard" }, "torpedo_expert_learned": { "n": 20000, "mean": 46.8, "sd": 8.36, "se_mean": 0.059, "median": 46.0, "p10": 37.0, "p90": 57.0, "min": 21, "max": 68, "pct_within_50": 66.57, "label": "Torpedo Expert (after 20 games vs. this player)" } }, "edge_touch": { "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 20000, "mean": 55.07, "sd": 8.26, "se_mean": 0.058, "median": 56.0, "p10": 43.0, "p90": 65.0, "min": 24, "max": 74, "pct_within_50": 27.87, "label": "Hunt/target + parity" }, "density": { "n": 20000, "mean": 49.48, "sd": 8.01, "se_mean": 0.057, "median": 49.0, "p10": 40.0, "p90": 61.0, "min": 29, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 57.06, "label": "Probability density" }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 20000, "mean": 49.03, "sd": 8.02, "se_mean": 0.057, "median": 48.0, "p10": 39.0, "p90": 61.0, "min": 27, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 60.78, "label": "Torpedo Hard" }, "torpedo_expert_learned": { "n": 20000, "mean": 47.35, "sd": 7.65, "se_mean": 0.054, "median": 46.0, "p10": 38.0, "p90": 58.0, "min": 27, "max": 70, "pct_within_50": 67.44, "label": "Torpedo Expert (after 20 games vs. this player)" } }, "centre": { "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 20000, "mean": 48.86, "sd": 10.55, "se_mean": 0.075, "median": 50.0, "p10": 34.0, "p90": 63.0, "min": 19, "max": 72, "pct_within_50": 53.02, "label": "Hunt/target + parity" }, "density": { "n": 20000, "mean": 42.49, "sd": 11.85, "se_mean": 0.084, "median": 43.0, "p10": 25.0, "p90": 59.0, "min": 17, "max": 71, "pct_within_50": 74.15, "label": "Probability density" }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 20000, "mean": 42.45, "sd": 11.83, "se_mean": 0.084, "median": 43.0, "p10": 25.0, "p90": 59.0, "min": 17, "max": 71, "pct_within_50": 74.59, "label": "Torpedo Hard" }, "torpedo_expert_learned": { "n": 20000, "mean": 36.27, "sd": 11.98, "se_mean": 0.085, "median": 35.0, "p10": 23.0, "p90": 53.0, "min": 17, "max": 67, "pct_within_50": 82.36, "label": "Torpedo Expert (after 20 games vs. this player)" } }, "cluster": { "hunt_target_parity": { "n": 20000, "mean": 47.22, "sd": 10.53, "se_mean": 0.074, "median": 48.0, "p10": 33.0, "p90": 61.0, "min": 20, "max": 72, "pct_within_50": 59.14, "label": "Hunt/target + parity" }, "density": { "n": 20000, "mean": 43.29, "sd": 11.07, "se_mean": 0.078, "median": 43.0, "p10": 28.0, "p90": 59.0, "min": 18, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 73.47, "label": "Probability density" }, "torpedo_hard": { "n": 20000, "mean": 43.67, "sd": 11.07, "se_mean": 0.078, "median": 43.0, "p10": 29.0, "p90": 59.0, "min": 17, "max": 73, "pct_within_50": 72.52, "label": "Torpedo Hard" }, "torpedo_expert_learned": { "n": 20000, "mean": 42.18, "sd": 10.75, "se_mean": 0.076, "median": 41.0, "p10": 28.0, "p90": 57.0, "min": 17, "max": 72, "pct_within_50": 76.05, "label": "Torpedo Expert (after 20 games vs. this player)" } } } }, "validation_vs_swift": { "note": "Python port vs. the app's own Swift ComputerPlayer, both against fleets from Board.random (not uniform)", "rows": { "classic/beginner": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 73.41, "python_se": 0.074, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 73.53, "swift_se": 0.147, "z": -0.75 }, "classic/easy": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 64.61, "python_se": 0.092, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 64.74, "swift_se": 0.186, "z": -0.64 }, "classic/normal": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 49.72, "python_se": 0.058, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 49.71, "swift_se": 0.117, "z": 0.11 }, "classic/hard": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 44.75, "python_se": 0.065, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 44.6, "swift_se": 0.132, "z": 1.0 }, "classic/expert": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 44.67, "python_se": 0.065, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 44.48, "swift_se": 0.129, "z": 1.31 }, "classic10/beginner": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 66.64, "python_se": 0.047, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 66.51, "swift_se": 0.097, "z": 1.18 }, "classic10/easy": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 63.24, "python_se": 0.048, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 63.21, "swift_se": 0.094, "z": 0.24 }, "classic10/normal": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 57.93, "python_se": 0.049, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 57.87, "swift_se": 0.1, "z": 0.58 }, "classic10/hard": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 55.18, "python_se": 0.048, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 55.1, "swift_se": 0.097, "z": 0.7 }, "classic10/expert": { "python_n": 20000, "python_mean": 55.16, "python_se": 0.048, "swift_n": 5000, "swift_mean": 55.17, "swift_se": 0.098, "z": -0.08 } } }, "heatmaps": { "classic_uniform": { "label": "Classic 5-ship fleet, uniform random legal layouts (rejection sampling, exact uniform)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 0.08003, 0.11486, 0.14358, 0.1589, 0.16665, 0.16678, 0.15881, 0.14362, 0.11491, 0.08007 ], [ 0.11531, 0.14304, 0.1659, 0.17767, 0.18408, 0.18384, 0.17755, 0.16541, 0.14261, 0.11499 ], [ 0.14359, 0.16565, 0.18434, 0.19402, 0.19957, 0.19912, 0.19402, 0.1839, 0.1652, 0.1433 ], [ 0.15915, 0.17797, 0.19427, 0.20343, 0.2085, 0.20826, 0.20358, 0.19426, 0.1776, 0.1585 ], [ 0.16673, 0.18421, 0.19957, 0.20868, 0.21387, 0.2136, 0.20861, 0.19928, 0.18424, 0.16637 ], [ 0.16684, 0.18386, 0.19921, 0.20847, 0.21346, 0.21332, 0.2086, 0.19908, 0.18425, 0.16641 ], [ 0.15869, 0.1777, 0.19422, 0.20359, 0.20827, 0.20839, 0.2033, 0.19385, 0.17764, 0.15846 ], [ 0.14353, 0.16555, 0.18428, 0.19423, 0.19949, 0.19948, 0.19417, 0.18418, 0.16564, 0.14346 ], [ 0.11474, 0.14248, 0.16549, 0.17766, 0.18404, 0.18423, 0.17725, 0.16525, 0.14248, 0.11461 ], [ 0.08013, 0.11522, 0.14374, 0.15897, 0.16679, 0.16681, 0.15839, 0.14332, 0.11479, 0.07998 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 0.21387 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "J10", "value": 0.07998 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 0.21387 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 0.2136 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 0.21346 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 0.21332 }, { "cell": "D5", "value": 0.20868 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "J10", "value": 0.07998 }, { "cell": "A1", "value": 0.08003 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 0.08007 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 0.08013 }, { "cell": "J9", "value": 0.11461 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 0.21356, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 0.08006, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 2.668, "max_to_min_ratio": 2.674, "board_mean": 0.17, "n_layouts": 4000000, "max_standard_error": 0.000205, "rejection_acceptance_rate": 0.3888, "check_max_abs_diff_vs_importance_sampling": 0.00069 }, "classic_sequential": { "label": "classic: Torpedo's own random placer (Board.random, ships placed one by one)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 0.07389, 0.10857, 0.13675, 0.15071, 0.15735, 0.15753, 0.15091, 0.13691, 0.109, 0.07395 ], [ 0.10926, 0.14073, 0.16613, 0.17847, 0.18497, 0.18471, 0.17826, 0.16613, 0.14066, 0.10864 ], [ 0.13668, 0.1656, 0.18888, 0.20033, 0.20604, 0.20616, 0.20032, 0.18883, 0.16609, 0.13638 ], [ 0.15077, 0.17847, 0.20051, 0.21102, 0.21673, 0.2168, 0.21089, 0.20036, 0.17864, 0.15035 ], [ 0.15757, 0.18444, 0.20637, 0.21625, 0.22181, 0.22207, 0.21687, 0.20606, 0.18508, 0.15731 ], [ 0.15766, 0.18461, 0.20654, 0.21661, 0.2222, 0.22201, 0.217, 0.20582, 0.18479, 0.15718 ], [ 0.1506, 0.17821, 0.20054, 0.21136, 0.21677, 0.21658, 0.21141, 0.20014, 0.17865, 0.1503 ], [ 0.13724, 0.16622, 0.18983, 0.20048, 0.2065, 0.20601, 0.20073, 0.1893, 0.16638, 0.13695 ], [ 0.1092, 0.1409, 0.16618, 0.17847, 0.18502, 0.18442, 0.17826, 0.16551, 0.14056, 0.10898 ], [ 0.07437, 0.10942, 0.13725, 0.15059, 0.15765, 0.15722, 0.15079, 0.13668, 0.1088, 0.07391 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "E6", "value": 0.2222 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 0.07389 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "E6", "value": 0.2222 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 0.22207 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 0.22201 }, { "cell": "E5", "value": 0.22181 }, { "cell": "G6", "value": 0.217 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 0.07389 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 0.07391 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 0.07395 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 0.07437 }, { "cell": "B1", "value": 0.10857 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 0.22202, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 0.07403, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 2.999, "max_to_min_ratio": 3.007, "board_mean": 0.17, "n_layouts": 2000000 }, "classic_sequential_reweighted_to_uniform": { "label": "classic: sequential draws re-weighted to uniform (importance sampling)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 0.07973, 0.11451, 0.14328, 0.15867, 0.16653, 0.16674, 0.15895, 0.14348, 0.11499, 0.0799 ], [ 0.11515, 0.14266, 0.16558, 0.17774, 0.18454, 0.18428, 0.17755, 0.16558, 0.14256, 0.11458 ], [ 0.14321, 0.16511, 0.18372, 0.19391, 0.19934, 0.1995, 0.19395, 0.18373, 0.1656, 0.14293 ], [ 0.15876, 0.17775, 0.19412, 0.20313, 0.20849, 0.20857, 0.20306, 0.19405, 0.17794, 0.15831 ], [ 0.16677, 0.1841, 0.19978, 0.20808, 0.21342, 0.21367, 0.20859, 0.19943, 0.18464, 0.16647 ], [ 0.16689, 0.18417, 0.1999, 0.20836, 0.21376, 0.21359, 0.20876, 0.1992, 0.18438, 0.1663 ], [ 0.15863, 0.17748, 0.19424, 0.20355, 0.20857, 0.20837, 0.20351, 0.19378, 0.17791, 0.15822 ], [ 0.14384, 0.16566, 0.18469, 0.19412, 0.19986, 0.19936, 0.19428, 0.1842, 0.16587, 0.14354 ], [ 0.11512, 0.14279, 0.16563, 0.17772, 0.1846, 0.18397, 0.17746, 0.16497, 0.14249, 0.11497 ], [ 0.0803, 0.11542, 0.14382, 0.15856, 0.16687, 0.16644, 0.15878, 0.14328, 0.11478, 0.07988 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "E6", "value": 0.21376 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 0.07973 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "E6", "value": 0.21376 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 0.21367 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 0.21359 }, { "cell": "E5", "value": 0.21342 }, { "cell": "G6", "value": 0.20876 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 0.07973 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 0.07988 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 0.0799 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 0.0803 }, { "cell": "B1", "value": 0.11451 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 0.21361, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 0.07995, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 2.672, "max_to_min_ratio": 2.681, "board_mean": 0.17, "n_layouts": 2000000, "effective_sample_size": 1964897 }, "ten_sequential": { "label": "classic10: Torpedo's own random placer (Board.random, ships placed one by one)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 0.18348, 0.19954, 0.20836, 0.20896, 0.20646, 0.20616, 0.20889, 0.20833, 0.19925, 0.18342 ], [ 0.19933, 0.19614, 0.19924, 0.19695, 0.19295, 0.19289, 0.19699, 0.19975, 0.19595, 0.19934 ], [ 0.20889, 0.19968, 0.20447, 0.2025, 0.19838, 0.19819, 0.20179, 0.2041, 0.19967, 0.20861 ], [ 0.2088, 0.19678, 0.20242, 0.20097, 0.19725, 0.19759, 0.20092, 0.20226, 0.19669, 0.20895 ], [ 0.20676, 0.19294, 0.19861, 0.19771, 0.19373, 0.19417, 0.19773, 0.19848, 0.19301, 0.20608 ], [ 0.20628, 0.19296, 0.1985, 0.19785, 0.19378, 0.19416, 0.19747, 0.19848, 0.19325, 0.20647 ], [ 0.20925, 0.19677, 0.2022, 0.20133, 0.19733, 0.19738, 0.2013, 0.20205, 0.19696, 0.20911 ], [ 0.20881, 0.19932, 0.20394, 0.20234, 0.1985, 0.19841, 0.20222, 0.20432, 0.19928, 0.20853 ], [ 0.19925, 0.19564, 0.19911, 0.19678, 0.19282, 0.1931, 0.19687, 0.19971, 0.19568, 0.1995 ], [ 0.18316, 0.19909, 0.2086, 0.2089, 0.20639, 0.20633, 0.20906, 0.20875, 0.19892, 0.18325 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "A7", "value": 0.20925 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A10", "value": 0.18316 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "A7", "value": 0.20925 }, { "cell": "J7", "value": 0.20911 }, { "cell": "G10", "value": 0.20906 }, { "cell": "D1", "value": 0.20896 }, { "cell": "J4", "value": 0.20895 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "A10", "value": 0.18316 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 0.18325 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 0.18342 }, { "cell": "A1", "value": 0.18348 }, { "cell": "E9", "value": 0.19282 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 0.19396, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 0.18333, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 1.058, "max_to_min_ratio": 1.142, "board_mean": 0.2, "n_layouts": 4000000 }, "ten_sequential_reweighted_to_uniform": { "label": "classic10: sequential draws re-weighted to uniform (importance sampling)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 0.23667, 0.22564, 0.25612, 0.25161, 0.24749, 0.24698, 0.25164, 0.2563, 0.22561, 0.23655 ], [ 0.22545, 0.14816, 0.1678, 0.15494, 0.15458, 0.15455, 0.15512, 0.16797, 0.14789, 0.22529 ], [ 0.25713, 0.16801, 0.20426, 0.19242, 0.19464, 0.19453, 0.19239, 0.20376, 0.16782, 0.25634 ], [ 0.25182, 0.15487, 0.19271, 0.17777, 0.18005, 0.1804, 0.17757, 0.19254, 0.15478, 0.25149 ], [ 0.24817, 0.15476, 0.1948, 0.1805, 0.18225, 0.18272, 0.18064, 0.19459, 0.15442, 0.24696 ], [ 0.24741, 0.15466, 0.19462, 0.18033, 0.18207, 0.18243, 0.18003, 0.19437, 0.15476, 0.24769 ], [ 0.25183, 0.15451, 0.19253, 0.17863, 0.18027, 0.18004, 0.17836, 0.19229, 0.15499, 0.25179 ], [ 0.25658, 0.16745, 0.20318, 0.19281, 0.19466, 0.19463, 0.1927, 0.2037, 0.16741, 0.25644 ], [ 0.2255, 0.14789, 0.1675, 0.15494, 0.15462, 0.15454, 0.15455, 0.16786, 0.14761, 0.22573 ], [ 0.23596, 0.22517, 0.25618, 0.25135, 0.24765, 0.24759, 0.25205, 0.25659, 0.22527, 0.23682 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "A3", "value": 0.25713 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "I9", "value": 0.14761 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "A3", "value": 0.25713 }, { "cell": "H10", "value": 0.25659 }, { "cell": "A8", "value": 0.25658 }, { "cell": "J8", "value": 0.25644 }, { "cell": "J3", "value": 0.25634 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "I9", "value": 0.14761 }, { "cell": "B9", "value": 0.14789 }, { "cell": "I2", "value": 0.14789 }, { "cell": "B2", "value": 0.14816 }, { "cell": "I5", "value": 0.15442 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 0.18237, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 0.2365, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 0.771, "max_to_min_ratio": 1.742, "board_mean": 0.2, "n_layouts": 4000000, "effective_sample_size": 1821508 }, "ten_uniform": { "label": "Classic 10 fleet (no touching), uniform random legal layouts (Gibbs sampler, 100 sweeps)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 0.23572, 0.22522, 0.2567, 0.25167, 0.24722, 0.24696, 0.25127, 0.25646, 0.22527, 0.23684 ], [ 0.22468, 0.14777, 0.16778, 0.15486, 0.15469, 0.15478, 0.15501, 0.16876, 0.14768, 0.22619 ], [ 0.25614, 0.16808, 0.20445, 0.19285, 0.19517, 0.19474, 0.19246, 0.20442, 0.16723, 0.25668 ], [ 0.25121, 0.15517, 0.19329, 0.17785, 0.18022, 0.17988, 0.17838, 0.19213, 0.15395, 0.25146 ], [ 0.24768, 0.15518, 0.19445, 0.17992, 0.18238, 0.18163, 0.1808, 0.19431, 0.15488, 0.24703 ], [ 0.24788, 0.1547, 0.19476, 0.18065, 0.1828, 0.18244, 0.18106, 0.19419, 0.1548, 0.24688 ], [ 0.25147, 0.15437, 0.19246, 0.17793, 0.18011, 0.18014, 0.17882, 0.1927, 0.15559, 0.25185 ], [ 0.25663, 0.16743, 0.20375, 0.19301, 0.19522, 0.19498, 0.19293, 0.20382, 0.16772, 0.25636 ], [ 0.22526, 0.14738, 0.16748, 0.15474, 0.1545, 0.15427, 0.15488, 0.16757, 0.1478, 0.22512 ], [ 0.23645, 0.22529, 0.25696, 0.25171, 0.24706, 0.24764, 0.25157, 0.25616, 0.22484, 0.23629 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "C10", "value": 0.25696 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "B9", "value": 0.14738 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "C10", "value": 0.25696 }, { "cell": "C1", "value": 0.2567 }, { "cell": "J3", "value": 0.25668 }, { "cell": "A8", "value": 0.25663 }, { "cell": "H1", "value": 0.25646 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "B9", "value": 0.14738 }, { "cell": "I2", "value": 0.14768 }, { "cell": "B2", "value": 0.14777 }, { "cell": "I9", "value": 0.1478 }, { "cell": "I4", "value": 0.15395 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 0.18231, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 0.23633, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 0.771, "max_to_min_ratio": 1.744, "board_mean": 0.2, "n_layouts": 1000000, "max_standard_error_if_independent": 0.000437, "check_max_abs_diff_vs_5_sweeps": 0.00261, "check_max_abs_diff_vs_importance_sampling": 0.00109 }, "cluster_layout_share": { "share_of_uniform_layouts_that_form_one_connected_group": 0.00981, "note": "acceptance of the cluster rejection sampler divided by the plain no-overlap acceptance" }, "empty_board_density_classic": { "label": "Classic fleet: number of single-ship placements covering each square on an empty board (exact count, summed over the 5 ships)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 10.0, 15.0, 19.0, 21.0, 22.0, 22.0, 21.0, 19.0, 15.0, 10.0 ], [ 15.0, 20.0, 24.0, 26.0, 27.0, 27.0, 26.0, 24.0, 20.0, 15.0 ], [ 19.0, 24.0, 28.0, 30.0, 31.0, 31.0, 30.0, 28.0, 24.0, 19.0 ], [ 21.0, 26.0, 30.0, 32.0, 33.0, 33.0, 32.0, 30.0, 26.0, 21.0 ], [ 22.0, 27.0, 31.0, 33.0, 34.0, 34.0, 33.0, 31.0, 27.0, 22.0 ], [ 22.0, 27.0, 31.0, 33.0, 34.0, 34.0, 33.0, 31.0, 27.0, 22.0 ], [ 21.0, 26.0, 30.0, 32.0, 33.0, 33.0, 32.0, 30.0, 26.0, 21.0 ], [ 19.0, 24.0, 28.0, 30.0, 31.0, 31.0, 30.0, 28.0, 24.0, 19.0 ], [ 15.0, 20.0, 24.0, 26.0, 27.0, 27.0, 26.0, 24.0, 20.0, 15.0 ], [ 10.0, 15.0, 19.0, 21.0, 22.0, 22.0, 21.0, 19.0, 15.0, 10.0 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 34.0 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 10.0 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "E4", "value": 33.0 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "J10", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "A1", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "I10", "value": 15.0 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 34.0, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 10.0, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 3.4, "max_to_min_ratio": 3.4, "board_mean": 24.8, "total_placements": 760 }, "empty_board_density_ten": { "label": "Classic 10 fleet: single-ship placements covering each square (exact count, summed over the 10 ships, 1-square ships counted once per square)", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 16.0, 22.0, 25.0, 26.0, 26.0, 26.0, 26.0, 25.0, 22.0, 16.0 ], [ 22.0, 28.0, 31.0, 32.0, 32.0, 32.0, 32.0, 31.0, 28.0, 22.0 ], [ 25.0, 31.0, 34.0, 35.0, 35.0, 35.0, 35.0, 34.0, 31.0, 25.0 ], [ 26.0, 32.0, 35.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 35.0, 32.0, 26.0 ], [ 26.0, 32.0, 35.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 35.0, 32.0, 26.0 ], [ 26.0, 32.0, 35.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 35.0, 32.0, 26.0 ], [ 26.0, 32.0, 35.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 36.0, 35.0, 32.0, 26.0 ], [ 25.0, 31.0, 34.0, 35.0, 35.0, 35.0, 35.0, 34.0, 31.0, 25.0 ], [ 22.0, 28.0, 31.0, 32.0, 32.0, 32.0, 32.0, 31.0, 28.0, 22.0 ], [ 16.0, 22.0, 25.0, 26.0, 26.0, 26.0, 26.0, 25.0, 22.0, 16.0 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "D4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "E4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "F4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "G4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "D5", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "E5", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "G5", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "D6", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "G6", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "D7", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "E7", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "F7", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "G7", "value": 36.0 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 16.0 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "D4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "E4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "F4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "G4", "value": 36.0 }, { "cell": "D5", "value": 36.0 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "J10", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "A1", "value": 16.0 }, { "cell": "I10", "value": 22.0 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 36.0, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 16.0, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 2.25, "max_to_min_ratio": 2.25, "board_mean": 30.0 }, "empty_board_density_carrier": { "label": "Carrier (5) alone: placements covering each square", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 6.0, 5.0, 4.0, 3.0, 2.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 7.0, 6.0, 5.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 8.0, 7.0, 6.0, 5.0, 4.0 ], [ 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 9.0, 9.0, 8.0, 7.0, 6.0, 5.0 ], [ 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0, 10.0, 9.0, 8.0, 7.0, 6.0 ], [ 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0, 10.0, 9.0, 8.0, 7.0, 6.0 ], [ 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 9.0, 9.0, 8.0, 7.0, 6.0, 5.0 ], [ 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 8.0, 7.0, 6.0, 5.0, 4.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 7.0, 6.0, 5.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 6.0, 5.0, 4.0, 3.0, 2.0 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 10.0 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 2.0 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 10.0 }, { "cell": "E4", "value": 9.0 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "J10", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "A1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "I10", "value": 3.0 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 10.0, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 2.0, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 5.0, "max_to_min_ratio": 5.0, "board_mean": 6.0 }, "empty_board_density_destroyer": { "label": "Destroyer (2) alone: placements covering each square", "grid_rows_1_to_10_cols_A_to_J": [ [ 2.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 2.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 3.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0, 3.0 ], [ 2.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 2.0 ] ], "hottest": [ { "cell": "B2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I3", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I4", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I5", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I6", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I7", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I8", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "B9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "G9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "H9", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "I9", "value": 4.0 } ], "coldest": [ { "cell": "A1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "J10", "value": 2.0 } ], "top5": [ { "cell": "B2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "C2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "D2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "E2", "value": 4.0 }, { "cell": "F2", "value": 4.0 } ], "bottom5": [ { "cell": "J10", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "A10", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "J1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "A1", "value": 2.0 }, { "cell": "I10", "value": 3.0 } ], "centre_mean_E5_F5_E6_F6": 4.0, "corner_mean_A1_J1_A10_J10": 2.0, "centre_to_corner_ratio": 2.0, "max_to_min_ratio": 2.0, "board_mean": 3.6 } }, "best_first_shot": { "classic": { "cells": [ "E5" ], "statistically_tied_within_2_se": [ "E5", "F5", "E6", "F6" ], "hit_probability": 0.2139, "board_average_hit_probability": 0.17, "corner_hit_probability_mean": 0.08006, "density_argmax_cells": [ { "cell": "E5", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "F5", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "E6", "value": 34.0 }, { "cell": "F6", "value": 34.0 } ] }, "classic10": { "cells": [ "C10" ], "statistically_tied_within_2_se": [ "C1", "H1", "A3", "J3", "A8", "J8", "C10", "H10" ], "hit_probability": 0.257, "board_average_hit_probability": 0.2, "corner_hit_probability_mean": 0.23633 } } }